Peer review

TELOS: Revista de Estudios Interdisciplinarios en Ciencias Sociales follows an editorial evaluation and peer-review process designed to ensure the scientific quality, originality, relevance, and methodological rigor of submitted manuscripts. This process is based on principles of transparency, confidentiality, impartiality, and editorial independence, promoting constructive evaluation that contributes to improving research quality and advancing knowledge in the social sciences.

Initial Editorial Evaluation

All submitted manuscripts undergo a preliminary assessment by the Editor and the Editorial Board to verify their alignment with the journal's focus and scope, compliance with submission guidelines, originality, academic quality, and relevance of their scientific contribution.

During this stage, manuscripts are screened using iThenticate, with a maximum similarity threshold of 20%. This procedure aims to identify textual similarities, potential citation omissions, and situations that may compromise scientific integrity. The results are carefully examined by the editorial team, considering the nature and context of the identified similarities. Therefore, the similarity percentage does not replace the academic assessment of the manuscript.

Manuscripts that fail to meet editorial requirements, exceed the established similarity threshold, or present substantial deficiencies may be returned to the authors for revision or rejected before proceeding to external peer review.

Peer Review System

TELOS employs a double-blind peer-review system, in which the identities of both authors and reviewers remain confidential throughout the evaluation process.

Manuscripts that successfully pass the initial editorial assessment are submitted to at least two (2) external reviewers who specialize in the relevant subject area. Reviewers are selected based on their academic expertise, research experience, and knowledge of the subject under investigation.

Reviewers must be independent of the editorial team and the publishing institution. Academic, professional, or personal relationships that could compromise the objectivity of the evaluation must be avoided.

The Editor is responsible for selecting and assigning reviewers, overseeing the evaluation process, and ensuring compliance with the procedures established by the journal.

Evaluation Criteria and Outcomes

Reviewers assess manuscripts based on originality, scientific relevance, thematic suitability, theoretical foundations, methodological coherence, quality of analysis, consistency of results, relevance of conclusions, and currency of bibliographic references.

Following the evaluation, reviewers may issue one of the following recommendations:

  1. Publishable with Minor Revisions: The manuscript meets the general requirements for publication but requires minor adjustments to its content, structure, writing, or presentation.

  2. Publishable with Major Revisions: The manuscript presents relevant scientific contributions but requires substantial revisions that must be addressed and verified before acceptance can be considered.

  3. Not Suitable for Publication: The manuscript presents significant scientific, methodological, or editorial deficiencies that prevent its recommendation for publication.

For an article to be accepted, it must receive two favorable evaluations after the authors have addressed the corresponding recommendations.

When substantial discrepancies arise between reviewers' reports, the Editor may request a third external evaluation to support the editorial decision.

The final decision regarding acceptance or rejection rests with the Editor, who may consult the Editorial Board in cases involving disputes, conflicting reviewer recommendations, or circumstances requiring additional assessment.

Reviewers' Responsibilities

Participation in the peer-review process at TELOS is voluntary and unpaid (ad honorem), reflecting reviewers' commitment to the development of the scientific community.

Reviewers must conduct their evaluations objectively, rigorously, respectfully, and confidentially. Before accepting a review assignment, they are required to disclose any potential conflicts of interest involving the authors, institutions, research topic, or other circumstances that could affect their independence. When a conflict of interest compromises their impartiality, reviewers must decline the assignment.

Manuscripts submitted for review are confidential documents and must not be shared, used, or disclosed without the journal's express authorization.

TELOS promotes a constructive and educational approach to peer review. Reviewers are therefore encouraged to provide clear, well-founded, and respectful comments that contribute to improving manuscript quality.

Reviewers may insert comments directly into manuscripts and use the journal's review form to organize and summarize their assessments and recommendations.

Editorial Process and Review Timelines

The journal establishes the following estimated timelines for the evaluation process:

  • Initial editorial evaluation: Within the first two (2) weeks following manuscript submission.

  • External peer review: Between four (4) and ten (10) weeks, depending on the volume of manuscripts received, the backlog of articles undergoing evaluation, and the availability of qualified reviewers.

  • Third review, when required: An additional period of two (2) to four (4) weeks may be necessary.

  • Communication of results: Once the reviewers' reports have been received, the Editor will notify the authors of the corresponding comments, recommendations, or editorial decisions through the journal's editorial platform.

These timelines are estimates and may vary depending on manuscript complexity, reviewer availability, and the need for additional evaluations.

The editorial team monitors compliance with the established timelines and seeks to keep authors informed about the status of their submissions.

Revisions and Editorial Decision

When reviewers recommend revisions, authors must submit a revised version of the manuscript accompanied by a response to the reviewers' comments, indicating the changes made or providing academically justified explanations for recommendations that have not been incorporated.

The Editor will verify whether the requested revisions have been adequately addressed and, when appropriate, may return the manuscript to the reviewers to confirm that substantial concerns have been satisfactorily resolved.

Final acceptance depends on compliance with the journal's scientific quality standards, reviewers' recommendations, and editorial policies.

Post-Acceptance Procedures

Accepted manuscripts undergo copyediting, spelling and grammar corrections, and formatting adjustments in accordance with the journal's editorial standards, while preserving the meaning and integrity of the original scientific content.

Before publication, the final version will be sent to the authors for review and approval to identify any potential editing or presentation errors.

Acceptance of a manuscript does not exempt authors from their responsibility for the originality, accuracy, and scientific quality of the published content.

Review Form

Reviewers use the evaluation form established by TELOS to record their comments and recommendations, contributing to consistency, transparency, and traceability throughout the peer-review process.

Consult the TELOS Peer Review Form.