Hacia una teoría general de la extrafiscalidad tributaria: postulados fundacionales y evidencia comparada en México y Colombia

Authors

  • Pedro José Arrieta Meléndez Corporación Politécnico de la Costa Atlántica (PCA) Author

Keywords:

taxation, fiscal policy, income tax, tax law

Abstract

Contemporary tax law increasingly resorts to taxation for purposes other than redistributive, regulatory, environmental and promotional collection purposes, intensifying the use of taxation for different purposes without accompanying it with a development of tax doctrine at the same time. Taking as a starting point the tax dogmatics of Jarach, Tipke and Lang, García Novoa and Pérez Royo, which is complemented by the contributions of Musgrave and Pigou in the key of public economics, this article will formulate the first approach to an initial General Theory of Extra-taxation (TGET); that is, the first approach to a conceptual framework formulated as a system of postulates, principles, categories and evaluation criteria. The proposal is supported by contextual evidence of the income tax of Mexico and Colombia, within the period 2006-2022 from a mixed study methodology (documentary and jurisprudential review, interviews with six specialists and a Likert-type survey of 120 tax professionals which was analyzed by correlation of Spearman ranges and internal consistency of the instrument (Cronbach's alpha=0.7353). The results point in the direction of the systematic existence of extra-fiscal functions in a more or less powerful way in both. Perceptual evidence does not in itself demonstrate the need for a general theory, but rather provides diagnostic support for an   argument   constructed   primarily  by  doctrinal  means.  The study  delimits  the contribution of the TGET in the face of the existing doctrine, formulates five postulates, five guiding principles and four analytical categories, discusses  foreseeable objections and makes explicit conditions for refutation. It is concluded that extra-taxation constitutes a relevant legal function of the contemporary constitutional State whose theoretical systematization requires explicit criteria of legitimacy, effectiveness, proportionality, evaluability and periodic review within the constitutional order.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Published

2026-08-26